Table 2 lists some of the special difficulties which cosmology has to face as a science. They are mostly obvious but it is worth emphasising one or two:
1. | Only one Universe. |
2. | Universe opaque for 56/60 decades since Planck era. |
3. | Need to extrapolate physics over huge distances. |
4. | Need to work with what we can currently detect. [But ...] |
5. | Local background very bright. |
6. | Distances very hard to determine (standard candles). |
7. | Observational Selection insidious. |
8. | Distant galaxies hard to measure and interpret unambiguously. |
9. | Luminosity Functions unreliable. |
10. | Geometry, astrophysics and evolution often entangled. |
11. | Physics of early Universe unknown (and unknowable?) |
12. | Human time-frame so short compared to cosmic. |
13. | Origin of inertia. |
14. | The singularity. |
In summary we have very few observations, most of them were accidently made, and all are subject to observational selection. It is therefore outrageous to claim a comparison with all the carefully controlled experiments made by particle physicists. And even if we do get a perfect map of the Cosmic Background Radiation it will only be a map of a moment in time. Celestial mechanics is very precise - but it doesn't tell us how the solar system was formed.