Published in "Astrophysical Journal", Vol. 86, p.217, 1937.

For a PDF version of the article, click here.
For a Postscript version of the article, click here.


ON THE MASSES OF NEBULAE AND OF CLUSTERS OF NEBULAE

F. Zwicky


Abstract. Present estimates of the masses of nebulae are based on observations of the luminosities and internal rotations of nebulae. It is shown that both these methods are unreliable; that from the observed luminosities of extragalactic systems only lower limits for the values of their masses can be obtained (sec. i), and that from internal rotations alone no determination of the masses of nebulae is possible (sec. ii). The observed internal motions of nebulae can be understood on the basis of a simple mechanical model, some properties of which are discussed. The essential feature is a central core whose internal viscosity due to the gravitational interactions of its component masses is so high as to cause it to rotate like a solid body.

In sections iii, iv, and v three new methods for the determination of nebular masses are discussed, each of which makes use of a different fundamental principle of physics.

Method iii is based on the virial theorem of classical mechanics. The application of this theorem to the Coma cluster leads to a minimum value bar M = 4.5 × 1010 Modot for the average mass of its member nebulae.

Method iv calls for the observation among nebulae of certain gravitational lens effects.

Section v gives a generalization of the principles of ordinary statistical mechanics to the whole system of nebulae, which suggests a new and powerful method which ultimately should enable us to determine the masses of all types of nebulae. This method is very flexible and is capable of many modes of application. It is proposed, in particular, to investigate the distribution of nebulae in individual great clusters.

As a first step toward the realization of the proposed program, the Coma cluster of nebulae was photographed with the new 18-inch Schmidt telescope on Mount Palomar. Counts of nebulae brighter than about m = 16.7 given in section vi lead to the gratifying result that the distribution of nebulae in the Coma cluster is very similar to the distribution of luminosity in globular nebulae, which, according to Hubble's investigations, coincides closely with the theoretically determined distribution of matter in isothermal gravitational gas spheres. The high central condensation of the Coma cluster, the very gradual decrease of the number of nebulae per unit volume at great distances from its center, and the hitherto unexpected enormous extension of this cluster become here apparent for the first time. These results also suggest that the current classification of nebulae into relatively few cluster nebulae and a majority of field nebulae may be fundamentally inadequate. From the preliminary counts reported here it would rather follow that practically all nebulae must be thought of as being grouped in clusters - a result which is in accord with the theoretical considerations of section v.

In conclusion, a comparison of the relative merits of the three new methods for the determination of nebular masses is made. It is also pointed out that an extensive investigation of great clusters of nebulae will furnish us with decisive information regarding the question whether physical conditions in the known parts of the universe are merely fluctuating around a stationary state or whether they are continually and systematically changing.

The determination of the masses of extragalactic nebulae constitutes at present one of the major problems in astrophysics. Masses of nebulae until recently were estimated either from the luminosities of nebulae or from their internal rotations. In this paper it will be shown that both these methods of determining nebular masses are unreliable. In addition, three new possible methods will be outlined.


Table of Contents

MASSES FROM LUMINOSITIES OF NEBULAE

MASSES FROM INTERNAL ROTATIONS OF NEBULAE
Model of a nebula whose "internal viscosity" is negligible
Model of a nebula whose internal viscosity is very great
Actual nebulae
Further discussion of the rotation of nebulae

THE VIRIAL THEOREM APPLIED TO CLUSTERS OF NEBULAE

NEBULAE AS GRAVITATIONAL LENSES

STATISTICAL DISTRIBUTION IN SPACE OF DIFFERENT TYPES OF NEBULAE

THE COMA CLUSTER OF NEBULAE

COMPARISON OF THE THREE METHODS

Next